electoral college and slavery In the Electoral College system the number of votes that each state gets is based on the size of its congressional delegation which in turn is determined by population. This is a fact. Ultimately delegates to the Constitutional Convention Mar 19 2019 The slave states wanted to have an electoral college to where the members that they had in Congress counted towards the vote of president where the slaves counted as two thirds in a popular Jul 13 2020 However with slavery abolished and universal suffrage granted to almost everyone over 21 many of the original reasons for the creation of the electoral college no longer exist. We believe that this obviously flawed system of choosing our President and Vice President is long Aug 31 2020 On the other side 21 senators voted in favor of preserving the Electoral College 10 from slave states and 11 from free states the senator s comment and the vote are here in the congressional Jul 15 2020 White supremacy is systemic. Edwards described the Electoral College s connection to slavery last Friday in the Washington Post Nov 22 2016 The Electoral College now consists of 538 electors. Small states of the North also had a chance using the electoral college. The South was the bulwark of opposition during the period of slavery of course because slave holding states received extra electoral votes thanks to the three fifths clause. com Enter email address to receive updates from Apr 05 2019 I appreciate your correction regarding the Electoral College and slavery. In the antebellum period the College assured that slave power shaped Presidential elections because of the notorious three fifths compromise which increased the electoral clout of slave states. The Electoral College was designed to protect an evil American institution slavery. It s doubtful even Alexander Hamilton believed what he was selling in Federalist No. Maybe it was one of the elite college gang like Dec 15 2016 The Electoral College an institution that helped to protect the white supremacist ignominy of black chattel slavery could now become the instrument used to stop Donald Trump the avatar of So the slaves states didn t want a popular election because their slaves wouldn t count towards voting and the slaves states would have less votes. Abolish the Electoral College was created to reform an antiquated system that we believe does not adequately represent the will of the people. I said as nbsp 10 Apr 2019 The Electoral College may not have been expressly designed only to protect African slavery but based on Madison 39 s notes it was the mode nbsp Slave states had a smaller ratio of voters to the total population but they had the three fifths compromise which took slaves into account in determining the nbsp 4 Aug 2020 The South was the bulwark of opposition during the period of slavery of course because slave holding states received extra electoral votes nbsp Were a slave state to free any blacks who then moved North the state could actually lose electoral votes. An electoral roll lists all the of the people eligible to vote in an electoral district. That system has allowed the loser of the popular vote to win the Presidency in five of our 56 Presidential elections. Sep 01 2020 Ultimately it was the Electoral College that led to slavery s destruction It made Abraham Lincoln president in 1860 even though the vast majority of Americans voted for someone else. The College 39 s primary purpose was not to give small states greater representation as is often claimed by its defenders today. The biggest flaw in standard civics accounts of the electoral college is that they never mention the real demon dooming direct national election in 1787 and 1803 slavery. So how does the Electoral College work The Electoral College is the important and often controversial process by which the United States selects the President of the United States every four ye In just a few days voters will be heading to the polls to cast their ballots for president and have been for the last few weeks well sort of. Lea I read your editorial on the electoral college and slavery. After Reconstruction you point out that Southern In its zeal to abolish the Electoral College the New York Times has chosen to repeat the falsehood that the institution was created to protect the interests of the slave holding states. Ultimately delegates While the electoral college is as old as the American Constitution it s also been controversial since the very beginning of the country. 5 percent but last in the Electoral College. Constitution in 1788. As Finkelman observes in 1800 Thomas Jefferson defeated the incumbent president John Adams solely because of the three fifths rule. When Dec 07 2016 What were they thinking when they allocated electoral votes among the states Prof. Although groups like the League of Women Voters have long supported the abolition of the electoral college 1 the protracted proceedings in Florida as well as the apparent disparity between the popular and the electoral college vote have further fueled calls to abolish the electoral college. It had nothing to do with slavery. Nov 21 2016 The story of the Electoral College is also one of slavery an institution central to the founding of American democracy. not the electoral Mar 20 2017 The Electoral College doubled down on another concession the three fifths rule to partially count non voting slaves and boost the census number that would determine how many Congressional districts and therefore electors each state ended up with. S. Even though slaves didn 39 t vote they were counted in the US census as three Aug 09 2020 The Electoral College is a vestige of slavery. Brooks Kraft Getty Images Since the United States Constitution was ratified there have been five Presidential elections where the candidate who won the popu It s doubtful even Alexander Hamilton believed what he was selling in Federalist No. 15 Jul 2020 In the last five elections the Electoral College has handed the presidency to As early as 1800 electoral votes attributable to slaves provided nbsp 13 May 2019 While slavery was an issue that loomed over the Constitutional Convention it had little to do with debates over how to elect the president. This is not a contentious claim it is undeniable gt gt fact. But the framers did not put it into the Constitution to protect the South. We are a republic. All Programs Remote Programs Education Programs Family Programs History After Dark Talks Films Tours nbsp 19 Mar 2019 quot The slave states wanted to have an Electoral College to where the members that they had in Congress counted towards the vote of president nbsp 21 Nov 2016 The story of the Electoral College is also one of slavery an institution central to the founding of American democracy. Mar 20 2019 Rep. You hear today that it s just about slavery and the southern slave owning states wanted to have an Electoral College. The Southern slave economy though nbsp 4 Apr 2019 Ultimately the Electoral College contributed to ending slavery since Abraham Lincoln having earned only 39. Electoral College has discouraged expansion of the franchise and resulted in five presidents nbsp 30 Nov 2001 Read Legal Commentary History Slavery Sexism The South And The Electoral College at FindLaw. Contested elections gt gt awarded excessive congressional representation to the slave states and gt gt the electoral college is based on congressional representation. 8 The few that notice slavery mention it only in passing and then ignore it perhaps because an extended investigation of slavery and the electoral college would undermine traditional political science categories. Today things are no different Almost 60 percent of Americans would be happy to see the electoral college go according to one poll from the Pew Research Center. Cohen then proceeded to allege that black Americans are directly experiencing slavery because of the Electoral College. At the Philadelphia convention the visionary Pennsylvanian James Wilson proposed direct national election of the president. Mar 23 2019 The Electoral College can be abolished or at least rendered moot in one of two ways by amending the Constitution or in a move by the states to tie their electors to the national vote rather According to Dr. gt gt gt . The electoral college was created in nbsp 4 May 2019 An April 30 letter said the Electoral College quot was put in place because the Founders didn 39 t trust democracy and voters. Many of the founding fathers mistrusted direct democracy the tyranny of the majority according to Alexis de Tocqueville and wanted Congress to choose the President. 2019 reprinted with permission for educational non commercial purposes. The Electoral College Primer for example notes in passing that Mar 20 2019 B lack voters have plenty to gain from replacing the electoral college a system built originally to protect the interest of white male slave owners with selecting presidents through a popular Larry P. Founded during the era of slavery the Electoral College is a reminder of America s past injustices. A majority of 270 electoral votes is required to elect the President. Lincoln only earned 39. Did You Know 21 Nov 2016 The Electoral College now consists of 538 electors. Ever forgotten how the electoral college works Refresh your memory before tonight s Presidential election Here are some reasons why the United States should retain the Electoral College system and what the founding fathers intended when they created it. Aug 04 2020 Modern Americans are repeatedly told that the Electoral College is evil founded in slavery. Aug 04 2020 All Americans should read this amp understand how deeply rooted the antiquated Electoral College system is in racism amp slavery the Motherless Brooklyn and Birdman star wrote on Twitter in response to the Times article. Finkelman didn 39 t have to quot prove quot anything. It was the result of a last minute compromise at the Apr 10 2019 A common charge made by critics of the Electoral College is that the institution was created simply to benefit slavery. Thus in the 1800 census the state of Pennsylvania had 10 more free persons then the much like the electoral college the manner in which Senators were chosen was initially left to the states for instance in the 1858 race for Illinois senator between Abraham Lincoln and Steven A Douglas there was a popular vote but it was irrelevant as the Illinois legislature overruled the pro Lincoln vote to hand the job to Douglas Sep 09 2020 The Electoral College is a system that traces its roots back to the founding of our nation and the legacy of white supremacy. Dec 06 2016 The Electoral College paid immediate dividends for the slave states. 22 Sep 2016 Don Robinson Electoral College remains relic of slavery. Jun 03 2019 The framers own damning words seem to cinch the case that the Electoral College was a pro slavery ploy. 19 Feb 2020 The National Popular Vote NPV plan is the latest in a long line of schemes designed to replace the Electoral College. Jamestown. The slave state forefathers refused to agree with one man one vote for presidential elections. Jul 15 2020 White supremacy is systemic. Jan 11 2019 The Electoral College had everything to do with balancing power between large and small states in America s new experiment in self governance. James Wilson proposed the use of a direct election by the people but he gained no support for this idea and it was decided that the president would be elected by Congress. I once argued with an associate at work who said that I was ignorant and very negative after making the statement that a citizen 39 s popular vote does not really count when you go into the booth to elect the Though the three fifths rule was gone with the abolition of slavery it had been replaced by something even worse for while blacks were effectively disenfranchised in most of the South their states now got full credit for their black populations in the House of Representatives and thus in the Electoral College. We deserve better. You can however check to see if an individual is registered to vote in an election. 11 Nov 2016 Southern states had a huge mass of people slaves who contributed to population size but could not vote. The Hill published a hilariously overwrought article earlier this week entitled How the Electoral College changes the value of a person a bit like slavery did. 9 million but it was the Republican who entered the White House with 304 electoral college votes to Clinton s 227. Above all the Virginia slaveholder James Madison the most influential delegate at the convention insisted that while direct popular election of the president was the fittest system it would hurt the South whose population Dec 01 2016 The Electoral College was all about slavery and protecting slave owners rights. Because you can win a majority of electoral college votes without nbsp slavery the electoral college and our post Reconstruction legacy of state voter suppression and disenfranchisement efforts. So the slaves states didn t want a popular election because their slaves wouldn t count towards voting and the The Electoral College system in which candidates must win enough states to surpass 270 electoral votes is deeply rooted in U. Originally published by History News Network 04. White Southerners thus gained added influence in the Electoral College and if they had switched to a national popular vote they would have lost that influence. Nov 28 2016 The Electoral College is the mode by which the country officially elects the President of the United States. You hear today that it s just about slavery and the southern slave owning states wanted to have an electoral college. It is the height of irony that if slaves had not been counted at all Adams would have won and the end of slavery might have been hastened. In the electoral college the st News Every four years as we approach our presidential elections a ripple of dissent occurs among the politically critical as we collectively remember that the Electoral College exists and that its members 538 members will decide who our next president is. Aug 23 2020 Long after the abolition of slavery Southern political leaders fought to maintain the Electoral College and dump the only truly Democratic way of voting which obviously is majority vote takes all. They could run the numbers as well as anyone and realized As the republic evolved so did the Electoral College system and by the late 19th century the following range of constitutional legal and political elements were in place on both a state and Between the first president George Washington and the 16th Abraham Lincoln 10 came from Southern slave states. Sean Wilentz is a professor of history at Princeton and the author most recently of No Property in Man Slavery and Antislavery at the Nation s Founding. Since the number of electoral votes was nbsp 29 Jul 2020 Your View Electoral College was designed to keep power from shifting from slave states with smaller voting populations is a prime example of nbsp 11 Jan 2019 Alexandria Ocasio Cortez and others have panned the Electoral College as a relic of slavery. Mar 20 2019 Attorney and election expert Tara Ross said the Electoral College has nothing to do with slavery during an interview with Fox amp Friends Wednesday. The Founding Fathers chose it as a compromise between allowing Congress to choose the president and having the president elected directly by the popular vote of the people. In this Essay I respond to nbsp 21 Mar 2019 Ditching the Electoral College is sound on the merits even apart from its connection to slavery which I 39 ll get to below . By this time the Convention had already agreed to count slaves for nbsp 8 Apr 2019 The majority of electors in the electoral college voted for Donald of Tennessee claims the system was designed to help the slave states. The electoral college mechanism was chosen because it solved these problems in the nbsp three fifths of the slave population in apportioning representation gave the South extra representation in the House and extra votes in the Electoral College. The slave states wanted to have an Electoral College where the members that they had in Congress counted towards the vote of president where the slaves counted as two thirds and in the popular vote they would count as zero. The three fifths compromise ensured white adult males in slaveholding states exercised disproportionate influence. Today the electoral nbsp The Electoral College contributed to President Lincoln 39 s election and the ending of slavery. Aug 30 2020 The Civil War ended slavery but not the Electoral College. Wilentz concludes that it is a myth to say that the Electoral College was a pro slavery ploy. Sep 02 2020 The issue of slavery was not a reason for the introduction of the Electoral College. Back in 1787 at the Constitutional Convention states read more gt Sep 01 2017 The Electoral College was established in 1788 by Article II of the US Constitution which also established the executive branch of the US government and was revised by the Twelfth Amendment ratified June 15 1804 the Fourteenth Amendment ratified July 1868 and the Twenty Third Amendment ratified Mar. Akhil Amar of Yale says the electoral vote count goes back to America 39 s o Ultimately the Electoral College contributed to ending slavery since Abraham Lincoln having earned only 39. The Electoral College process consists of the selection of the electors. As this brief electoral college history shows while it roughly tracks the total of votes citizens have cast in a presidential election popular vote results can be different. It permitted southern states to disfranchise large numbers of slaves while allowing these states to maintain nbsp 10 Oct 2007 of Representatives and the Electoral College lt li gt lt ul gt lt ul gt lt li gt The right to continue importing slaves from Africa stopped in 1808 lt li gt lt ul gt nbsp 30 Apr 2018 tweet to spark opposition says Republicans are actually the party of social justice because Abraham Lincoln quot freed and protected quot the slaves. On the first anniversary of the very odd election of 2000 it 39 s hard to look back without fixating on Florida and the courts. But with 15 states and counting supporting an interstate agreement to grant their electoral votes to the winner of the popular Aug 07 2020 The electoral college was also favoured by southern states where slaves made up a large portion of the population. Matt Smith Colleyville. Recall Finkleman 39 s Article And Outline The Two quot myths Or Mistruths quot He Aims To Disprove About Our Common Held Knowledge Around Why Jul 15 2020 From day one basically the slave states and the small states were advantaged by the Electoral College but slave states were advantaged more. The slave states wanted equal representation in the Senate because they wanted to keep slavery. As we may all remember dimly from high school when we vote for president we don t actually vote In just a few days voters will be heading to the po Learn about the purpose of the Electoral College along with the effects of using it to determine the winner of the U. Nothing has changed as to variety of state size populations. Photo Rhona Wise Stringer Getty Images Nov 11 2016 The Electoral College now consists of 538 electors. From a Southern perspective the system worked brilliantly. Sep 02 2020 While the 13th amendment which abolished slavery in effect removed the three fifths clause the impacts of an unbalanced electoral college with unequal representation remain. . But an Electoral College allows states to count slaves albeit at a discount Jul 06 2020 But there is one shameful remnant from the past that could keep Trump in office the Electoral College an antidemocratic relic of unconscionable compromises made at America s founding that Douglas was the only candidate who won electoral votes in both slave and free states free New Jersey and slave Missouri . The Civil War ended slavery nbsp 23 Aug 2020 Long after the abolition of slavery Southern political leaders fought to maintain the Electoral College and dump the only truly Democratic way of nbsp the states and the counting of slaves for purposes of presidential election. Nov 12 2016 But an Electoral College allows states to count slaves albeit at a discount the three fifths clause and that 39 s what gave the South the inside track in presidential elections. It is a system that was designed in the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia during the summer of 1787 and one of its chief architects is a man known to few Americans. The Electoral College was set up by slave owners quot to appease the Slavocracy quot as nbsp 19 Dec 2016 The Convention then accepted the idea of an Electoral College. Jul 15 2020 An oft repeated but false claim about the Electoral College is that it was created as part of a bargain to preserve slavery and bolster the political power of Southern states. The gt gt association is built into the very mechanics of the electoral college gt gt from the outset. He s the author of Why the Electoral College Is Bad for America. The real reason we have an Electoral College to protect slave states In a direct election system the South would have lost every time because a huge percentage of its population was slaves and slaves couldn 39 t vote. The racism critique ignores the nuances of history. By Paul Finkelman. 30 Aug 2019 Southern states also opposed electing the president based on a nationwide popular vote because slaves were not citizens and could not vote. quot Nothing could be nbsp Slavery and the Electoral College A Debate. A system that was created nearly 240 years ago with a compromise to placate an evil system of slavery. Nov 11 2016 Slavery ended with the Civil War but the Electoral College survives today as a historical remnant of slavery. But it is contained in the Constitution. At the same time the electoral college has caused some unique problems in modern elections. 18 Nov 2016 Was slavery the underlying cause for creating the Electoral College Nothing suggests that it was since the apportionment of electoral votes nbsp 8 Nov 2017 Beginnings of the System Steeped in Slavery and Racism. Abolishing the Electoral College was once an outrageous suggestion. 29 1961 . Rather than coming down to a simple total of the popular vote November s presidential election will be determined by the electoral vote as decided by the electoral college. Slavery and the Electoral College Author Constituitional Rights Foundation Damon Huss Subject Slavey and the Electoral College Keywords Slavey and the Electoral College Created Date 7 19 2019 8 16 49 PM The Electoral College is one of the many finely tuned institutions within the charter that have ensured stability and continuity in America for more than two centuries. The 13th Amendment to the Constitution freed the slaves in the U. Contributed. Yet neither allegation is true. May 10 2019 The Obsolescence Debate . Akhil Reed Amar is a professor at Yale Law Jul 29 2020 Your View Electoral College was designed to keep power from shifting from slave states with smaller voting populations is a prime example of systemic racism and should be abolished. As Time reports At the time the Twelfth Amendment tinkered with the Electoral College system rather than tossing it the system s pro slavery bias was hardly a secret. It is archaic undemocratic and potentially very dangerous. Jul 14 2020 How the Electoral College Is Tied to Slavery and the Three Fifths Compromise OG History is a Teen Vogue series where we unearth history not told through a white cisheteropatriarchal lens. A recent op ed in the Hickory Daily Record a local paper in North Carolina repeats this inaccurate charge and a few others as well. After the results of the 2016 U. Before we get to the Electoral College can we talk about Alexander Hamilton As a political figure Hamilton was vola News Every four years Americans are reminded that the electoral college is still important. gt gt gt gt You are monumentally stupid to tell such a fuckwitted lie thereby gt gt proving you didn 39 t read the law review article. She is nbsp 7 Aug 2020 Even though slaves didn 39 t vote they were counted in the US census as three fifths of a person . Sep 09 2020 Editor s Note An article in The Atlantic magazine makes the same argument that the issue over the Electoral College was slavery. Northern states did not. Constitutional compromises The Electoral College If a slave state had an amount of enslaved individuals that was not divisible by five would the United nbsp 16 Nov 2016 To come to Amar 39 s deductions on the Electoral College one must actively ignore the entire breadth of the Philadelphia Convention debates. Under the Electoral College system it is possible for a presidential candidate to lose the nationwide popular vote yet be elected president of the Uni The Electoral College System not the nationwide popular vote elects the president of the United States. Today we have new problems and we need new solutions. Aug 31 2020 On the other side 21 senators voted in favor of preserving the Electoral College 10 from slave states and 11 from free states the senator s comment and the vote are here in the congressional Nov 16 2016 In reading your article The Reasons for the Electoral College Feb. Just one nit I would pick with you. First let 39 s dispense with nbsp 9 Aug 2017 Yet as a matter of constitutional law and state electoral vote allocations Trump received a substantial majority of the votes in the electoral college nbsp 15 Dec 2016 Part of the Electoral College 39 s original purpose was to protect slave state power. The Electoral College operationalized the 3 5ths compromise and helped to secure extend and enhance the political power of the white slaveholding class whose epicenter at the end of the May 05 2020 Attitudes toward slavery played a part in every element of the Constitution s design from the creation of the Senate to the three fifths clause to the adoption of the Electoral College. The Civil War also changed the nation from a collection of states The United States are to an indivisible nation The History Slavery Sexism the South and the Electoral College. gt Mar 19 2019 The slave states wanted equal representation in the Senate because they wanted to keep slavery he said. They are both wrong. 9 of the popular vote in 1860 nbsp 1 Mar 2020 The stain of slavery is on the Electoral College as it is on all US history. Oct 30 2018 Earlier this month Democratic socialist congressional candidate Alexandria Ocasio Cortez tweeted her assertion that the Electoral College should be quot eliminated quot calling the time tested system quot a shadow of slavery s power on America today. presidential election the Race card was employed in an attempt to shame supporters of the college and the results of the recent election. DECEMBER 19 2016. Indeed there were urban areas even in Colonial times such as NYC Boston and Philadelphia. Instead the Electoral College was born from the effort of a radically democratic Pennsylvanian to persuade skeptical Southerners and New Nov 17 2019 And so the Electoral College s misfire in 1876 helped ensure that Reconstruction would not remove the original stain of slavery so much as smear it onto the other parts of the Constitution s Interests of slave holding states. It lives in policies like law and order policing and access to public goods and services. Newsletter. Ifthe system 39 s pro slavery tilt was not overwhelmingly nbsp 11 Jul 2020 The United States will hold a presidential election on 3 November with incumbent Republican Donald Trump up against Joe Biden the nbsp Actor Edward Norton has declared that the electoral college is deeply rooted in racism and slavery arguing that America should have started using a national nbsp 1 Mar 2020 This gave states in the South with many slaves more power despite the fact that large portions of their populations could not vote and were not nbsp 11 Nov 2016 Adopted to appease slaveholding states the U. To destroy it in a hail of Jul 08 2020 The Electoral College was then hardly a work of daring genius but a rather cautious clunky compromise influenced by slavery. In a The Electoral College is one of the many finely tuned institutions within the charter that have ensured stability and continuity in America for more than two centuries. Feb 24 2020 Eligible voters in each state elected the President by electing electors for the Electoral College and each state was given an amount of electors equal to its representation in the Senate and the House of Representatives. Hugh Williamson of North Carolina said on July 17 1787 that if the Constitution nbsp 20 Mar 2019 The South fought to preserve the institution of slavery while slave owning politicians fought to enshrine it in the constitution in the decades nbsp 28 Mar 2019 gest that the Electoral College lacks legitimacy because the Fram ers designed it to advantage the slave states. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. Oct 04 2019 The value of the electoral college has become an issue of public debate after multiple presidents in the past 20 years have been elected by the college despi Many voters will go to the polls in November ignorant of or baffled by the system which is used to choose the US President. 30 2001. The Electoral College with its basis in slavery should be changed so that the Electoral College votes go to the candidate that gets more votes of the people than the others. May 24 2019 The Electoral College was also not rigged to produce outcomes conducive to slavery. Nov 13 2016 Slavery was abolished but the Electoral College itself based on slavery remains. The Framers of US government feared the power of America 39 s true majority. Was the Electoral College designed as a pro slavery ploy to place undue influence in the hands of slaveholding states Using historical sources and precedents experts debate both sides that the College was put in place as a reasonable alternative to direct election of a president versus an effort by the founders to accommodate slavery. Oct 15 2018 The Electoral College was not designed to protect slavery. In a real sense the Electoral College was designed to support the political power of the Slave States. When one looks closer as Princeton historian Sean Mar 20 2019 The Electoral College was indirectly touched by the notorious slavery compromise only because states were allocated electors based on their senators and congressional districts and slaves were But the electoral college merely reflected the numbers not any bias about slavery and in any case the 3 5ths clause was not quite as proslavery a compromise as it seems since Southern Jul 20 2020 Slave states with many people and with fewer insisted on the Electoral College to preserve this advantage in presidential selection. 68. presidential election. Today 39 s breaking news and more in your inbox The Electoral College is the constitutionally specified process that the United States uses to elects its President and Vice President. Because of the Three Fifths Compromise which was an amendment that declared the slave population as three fifths of their The electoral college itself had nothing to do with slavery the discussions of the electoral college and the method of electing a president never occur in the context of any of the Dec 19 2016 Original Sin The Electoral College as a Pro Slavery Tool. quot quot The slave states wanted equal representation in the Senate So basically Edward Norton is completely correct to say that the Electoral College system is deeply rooted in racism and slavery which is a historical fact and cannot really be argued The Electoral College was devised to protect slavery in the US. I don 39 t expect the average American to know this because most of us are taught the Electoral College by teachers and professors who don 39 t understand it themselves either willfully or ignorantly. Editorial Supreme Court makes it official The Electoral College The Current Call for Change. The Electoral College is an institution created by Article II of the Constitution for the election of the president. The bulk of the new nation s citizenry resided in cities like Nov 12 2016 The Electoral College was designed at Philadelphia and was revised in the wake of the Jefferson Adams Burr election of 1800 1801 to advantage the slaveholding South wrote Yale Electoral college the system by which the president and vice president of the United States are chosen. However slavery was only one of the factors. gt gt slavery and the electoral college. In 2016 the Democrat Hillary Clinton won the popular vote with 65. 1 Jun 2019 Slave states wanted their slaves counted in their population numbers even though they weren 39 t citizens and could not vote in order to give nbsp 23 Mar 2019 Beating the rigged math as Obama did produced a backlash so strong that we sent Trump to the White House. Mar 20 2019 Attorney and election expert Tara Ross said the Electoral College has nothing to do with slavery during an interview with Fox amp Friends on Wednesday. In this compromise small states were protected by being given equal representation in the Senate. by Contributed November 19 2016 nbsp 5 Apr 2019 I used to favor amending the Electoral College in part because I believed the framers put it into the Constitution to protect slavery. The Electoral College was born. In the United States this information is not available to the general public. Can anyone nbsp 7 Jul 2020 Between the first president George Washington and the 16th Abraham Lincoln 10 came from Southern slave states. American political figures via unstrippedvoice. First the Electoral College should be eliminated. Had Nixon not achieved a majority of the electoral votes Wallace might have been in the position to choose and influence our next President. Above all the Virginia slaveholder James Madison the most influential delegate at Oct 25 2019 Mr. And the nbsp 10 Nov 2016 But Southern slave owner and future president James Madison shot down Wilson 39 s idea on the grounds that southern states could have no nbsp 16 Oct 2016 In a few weeks a granddaughter of a slave will cast one of the 29 Electoral College votes in New York to determine the next American nbsp 18 Nov 2016 This allowed for increased representation in southern slave states even though slaves could not vote. g. In his essay Wilentz reiterated his view first presented in a New York Times op ed that the Electoral College while deeply undemocratic was not part of a constitutional defense of slavery and Aug 12 2020 Norton wrote on Twitter All Americans should read this amp understand how deeply rooted the antiquated Electoral College system is in racism amp slavery. Arnn president of Hillsdale College defends the electoral college writing that in a deeply divided nation a candidate shouldn t be able to win by appealing only to urban sophisticates. Paul Finkelman Professor of law at Albany Law School and senior fellow of Pennsylvania program on Democracy Electoral College system was adopted due to slaves and remains the only legacy vestige of slavery in US constitution that is still affecting American political lives. Part One Of A Three part Series On The 2000 Election And The Electoral College Akhil Reed Amar amp Vikram David Amar Friday Nov. Jul 06 2020 The electoral college was created not due to slavery but due to the wide variety of state sizes. Jul 20 2020 Slave states with many people and with fewer insisted on the Electoral College to preserve this advantage to give them a similar advantage in presidential selection. No it wasn t and shame on whomever taught you it was. Steve Cohen D TN followed suit on Tuesday telling CNN the Electoral College was conceived in sin to perpetuat e slavery. We remember that our indirect election 14 Apr 2019 I look forward to continuing the debate on slavery and the Constitution which certainly includes the inception of the Electoral College but also nbsp 11 Apr 2019 Alexandria Ocasio Cortez it embodies a shadow of slavery 39 s power. Aug 25 2016 The Southern states favoured the electoral college system because while slaves had no votes under the constitution they were tallied as three fifths of a person in the census. Subsequently each state was given a nbsp 30 Nov 2000 the nonvoting slaves could nevertheless influence the presidential election Madison favored the creation of the electoral college. The interests of slave holding states may have influenced the choice of the Electoral College as the mode of electing the president. Instead the Electoral College was created to reflect the political realities associated with accommodating the institution of slavery into our electoral system. 07. He is explaining and elaborating on the association. The Civil War ended slavery and the three fifths of a man compromise but the Electoral College is still in place. 11 2008 including the rationale for the Electoral College I find that you give the wrong impression of why slaves were Sep 08 2019 But it didn t fix the real flaw the electoral system is grossly undemocratic and devised in large part as a protection for slave states which feared being outvoted in a popular vote system. Nov 06 2012 The Electoral College solved this problem according to George Edwards who is a presidential scholar at Oxford University and Texas A amp M. Nov 15 2016 If anything it was the electoral college that made it possible to end slavery since Abraham Lincoln earned only 39 percent of the popular vote in the election of 1860 but won a crushing victory Sep 01 2020 Ultimately it was the Electoral College that led to slavery s destruction It made Abraham Lincoln president in 1860 even though the vast majority of Americans voted for someone else. The Apr 10 2019 The Electoral College may not have been expressly designed only to protect African slavery but based on Madison s notes it was the mode most preferred by pro slavery forces. The Cohen criticized the Electoral College 39 s origins saying quot When the Constitution was drafted a lot of it had to do with slavery. Nov 19 2016 Slavery at that moment defined the balance of power in the Electoral College and in the nation. It is well past time we eliminate the Electoral College a shadow of slavery s power on America today that undermines our nation as a for the creation of the electoral college. 8 million to Donald Trump s 62. It would do so for James Madison s election for James Monroe 39 s and for those of several other Sep 20 2019 Like so many institutions rotting our crumbling empire to its core the electoral college was built entirely around the demands of slave owners. 11 Sep 2019 The North outnumbered the South in terms of the population the popular vote and the number of electors. The slave states wanted to have an electoral college to where the members that they had in Congress counted towards the vote of president where the slaves counted as two thirds in a popular vote they would count as zero. Will it redeem its history now 10 Dec 2016 To The Readers 39 Forum The Electoral College was a compromise of the Philadelphia constitutional convention. We should have moved to a national popular vote 200 years ago. 4 Apr 2019 Sean Wilentz NYT The Electoral College Was Not a Pro Slavery Ploy I used to favor amending the Electoral College in part because I nbsp My question is this I recently heard someone say that the electoral college was created in part to protect slave states and their rights to own slaves. However you 39 re wrong about slavery. Direct popular election of the nbsp 20 Mar 2017 For the fifth time the Electoral College the constitutional compromise of slave states Virginia yet it ended up with 20 fewer electoral votes. 9 of the popular vote in 1860 nevertheless won a crushing victory in the Electoral College leading many Southern slaveholders to stampede to secession in 1860 and 1861. That s one of the many talking points the Left has hurled against our electoral process. Ultimately delegates Feb 21 2017 In fact while the founders originally considered a presidential election system based solely on the popular vote they were largely swayed to the Electoral College according to constitutional scholar Akhil Reed Amar by the desire to balance between free states and slave states in the election of a president. com. As the general debate about the Electoral College heated up though and as the Electoral College s opponents began decrying its origins in slavery I thought I ought to write an essay on the Jul 28 2019 Three historians debate whether the Electoral College was written into the United States Constitution to provide a defense of slavery. It was devised by the framers of the United States Constitution to provide a method of election that was feasible desirable and consistent with a republican form of government. Or that it is outdated built for 18th century travel difficulties. It thrives in politics with systems that Americans rely on to elect leaders like the electoral college a process originally designed to protect the influence of white slave owners which is still used today to determine presidential elections. Mar 22 2019 President Trump once supported abolishing the Electoral College he previously felt it was a quot total disaster for democracy quot but since his 2016 presidential victory over Hillary Clinton in Mar 19 2019 The slave states wanted to have an Electoral College to where the members that they had in Congress counted towards the vote of president where the slaves counted as two thirds and in the popular vote they would count as zero. quot It is well past time we eliminate the Electoral College Dec 19 2016 Hamilton framed the Electoral College as a tyrant thwarting safety valve because the reality is infinitely less palatable The college was simply a sop to slave states that craved influence in the To prevent tie votes in the Electoral College which were made probable if not inevitable by the rise of political parties and no doubt to facilitate the election of a president and vice president of the same party the 12 th Amendment requires that each Elector cast one vote for president and a separate vote for vice president rather than Oct 09 2018 The US Electoral College is a vestige of slavery and needs to be abolished altogether says Alexandria Ocasio Cortez a Democratic socialist who is running to represent New York s 14th Congressional District. He then added We should have moved to a national popular vote 200 years ago. In mid July after the convention had settled on two of the most contentious debates of all over the nature and shape of Congress the delegates Jul 20 2020 Slave states with many people and with fewer insisted on the Electoral College to preserve this advantage to give them a similar advantage in presidential selection. Ultimately delegates Apr 01 2020 And so the Electoral College s misfire in 1876 helped ensure that Reconstruction would not remove the original stain of slavery so much as smear it onto the other parts of the Constitution s fabric and countenance the racialized patchwork democracy that endured until the passage of the Voting Rights Act of 1965. I didn 39 t need to quot cite quot Finkelman in The Electoral College was created in part as a compromise to give slaveholders more power. So a compromise was reached count slaves as 3 5 of a person and base the electoral votes on population plus two additional votes per state. The authors are Robert Apr 04 2019 The framers own damning words seem to cinch the case that the Electoral College was a pro slavery ploy. The formula for apportioning congressmen which is directly tied to the nbsp Going into the presidential election of 1860 the issue of slavery had heated the In the final Electoral College count Lincoln beat Breckinridge 180 votes to 72. Such a system would be illegal in any state or local election. Electoral College amp Slavery This is a political forum that is non biased non partisan and treats every persons position on topics equally. Hugh 27 Feb 2019 Professor Tedlow explains the Electoral College as it currently poor as well as the compromises necessary to get slave states to agree to the nbsp The Electoral College is a Compromise with Slavery. Nov 26 2018 Southerner Thomas Jefferson for example won the election of 1800 01 against Northerner John Adams in a race where the slavery skew of the electoral college was the decisive margin of victory Nov 06 2016 He said the Electoral College s three fifths clause enabled Thomas Jefferson who owned more than a hundred slaves to beat out in 1800 John Adams who was opposed to slavery since the South Mar 25 2019 The slave states wanted to have an Electoral College where the members that they had in Congress counted towards the vote of president where the slaves counted as two thirds and in the popular Apr 06 2019 When the Constitution was amended to modify the Electoral College after 1800 all America had seen the pro slavery tilt of the system but Jefferson s Southern allies steamrollered over Northern Jul 10 2020 Not only was the creation of the Electoral College in part a political workaround for the persistence of slavery in the United States but almost none of the Founding Fathers assumptions about Oct 12 2016 I am convinced that if Americans knew slavery was the issue behind the birth of the unpopular Electoral College it would ignite a powerful political movement in support of direct presidential voting. Jul 09 2020 Hence they created the Electoral College which benefited slavery and the South by giving every state no matter its population two extra votes reflective of its Senate representation and by lumping slaves into their population count by tallying them as three fifths of a person. Gregg II defends the Electoral College against the perennial charge that it was intended to defend the institution of slavery. Jul 23 2020 Slave states with many people and with fewer insisted on the Electoral College to preserve this advantage to give them a similar advantage in presidential selection. Apr 11 2019 But that was the only time a framer actually connected slavery and the electoral college. Mar 24 2019 The Electoral College a slavery era artifact that allows candidates to lose the popular vote yet still become president is undemocratic and discourages participation in the political process. To destroy it in a hail of Nov 16 2016 Standard civics class accounts of the Electoral College rarely mention the real demon dooming direct national election in 1787 and 1803 slavery. Nov 30 2001 The Key Role of Slavery in the History of the Electoral College. You repeatedly described the 3 5 compromise as a boon to slaveholders e. His support was the most widespread geographically he finished second behind Lincoln in the popular vote with 29. The Electoral College process consists of the selection of the electors. Despite popular belief the He concluded The Electoral College was part of a compromise and a compromise of slavery. TODAY DECEMBER 19 presidential electors will meet in the states to cast their ballots for the Jul 01 2020 Ultimately it was the Electoral College that led to slavery s destruction It made Abraham Lincoln president in 1860 even though the vast majority of Americans voted for someone else. the notorious provision that counted slaves as three fifths of a person to inflate the slave states apportionment in the new House of Representatives. And we should have it now. Nov 13 2018 To say the Electoral College was created to defend slavery and hence that was what kept our founders from choosing to have the president chosen by a popular national vote is to assume that Nov 12 2016 The 12th Amendment proposed in 1803 and passed a year later modified the Electoral College to its current form. history. Sep 05 2020 Question In The Reading quot The Proslavery Origins Of The Electoral College quot Finkleman Claims That At Its Core The Reason The Electoral College Was Created To Benefit Slave holding States And Expand Their Power. It provides that each state will appoint a Nov 11 2016 The Electoral College and the Popular Vote It 39 s theoretically possible that the Electoral College could upend the results of the 2016 presidential election but such an event would be unprecedented. Imbued with the ideals nbsp 6 Oct 2019 The 1619 Project reveals the enduring impact that slavery has had on the Electoral College for a reason other than to perpetuate slavery. In 1824 the presidential selection was thrown into the House of Representatives and John Quincy Adams was chosen over Andrew Jackson even though Jackson had a larger popular vote plurality. The Constitutional Convention If some of the most famous Patriots of the Revolution had attended a dark blemish on the history of the United States may well have been quite different. But it did not give them an electoral majority. Oct 22 2018 In 1787 the Electoral College was approved by the Constitutional Convention and since then it has not undergone any major changes. The bulk of the new nbsp 3 Jan 2017 Gary L. The Electoral College system was established by Article II of the U. 14 Nov 2016 Though Hillary Clinton defeated Donald Trump in the national popular vote Mr. Nov 11 2016 I have thumbed through various parts of Madison 39 s notes on the Constitutional Convention the Federalists and Anti Federalists papers and Ratification by Pauline Maier and I can find nothing in regards to the Electoral College and slavery. Nov 14 2016 Simply stated the Electoral College incentivized the institution of slavery it was created to protect and propagate the enslavement of black people. Trump is now President elect based on the indirect nbsp 19 Nov 2016 Here 39 s why the founders made the Electoral College to protect southern slave states. The Civil War ended slavery and the three fifths of a man compromise but the Electoral College is still in place. The Civil War that followed and the subsequent adoption of the Reconstruction Amendments to the Constitution eliminated the three fifths compromise The Electoral College now consists of 538 electors. Fact Check FALSE. Nothing could be further from the truth she said. Nothing could be further from the truth. Perhaps the most hopeful effort to reform America s election system is the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact in which each state agrees to award all of its electoral votes to the candidate who wins the popular vote. 9 of the popular vote in 1860. Jan 03 2017 To taint the Electoral College with the poison brush of slavery one first needs to leap back to the Great Compromise that created the Congress itself. Today the polarization between cities and rural areas is greater than ever. Apr 04 2019 The Electoral College Was Not a Pro Slavery Ploy There is a lot wrong with how we choose the president. Mar 20 2019 The electoral college exists because slave owning states wanted representation in the constitution relative to their population but they did not want their entire population to be represented in As the general debate about the Electoral College heated up though and as the Electoral College s opponents began decrying its origins in slavery I thought I ought to write an essay on the The Electoral College is an embarrassment to our nation and not just because it subverts the will of the voting majority. Nov 18 2016 The electoral college system for choosing the President was based upon the protection of slavery and a distrust of democracy. Nov 22 2016 A constitutional law professor explains how the Electoral College was established as a compromise between free states and slave states. Timothy Hoyer. Today the electoral college continues to serve the select few privileged during Jan 21 2018 The Electoral College was built in part to accommodate white male slave owners who could not have anticipated a two party system that slaves would be freed or that black people and women would Nov 19 2016 The claim that the Electoral College was enacted in order to protect the interests of slave owners is blatantly false. Dec 28 2016 The Electoral College is a racist system that helped slave states and that s why it should be abolished. electoral college and slavery

zbrl5erpun
enkbyvdqgdk1cm
yh1y0z4qhfywkd
nmvulifxbonayytxlpd
6xvur9tx8h1oo45